As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

A Reckoning in Mercy

A Classic Western Ghost Story

by T. E. MacArthur

A Reckoning in Mercy - T.E. MacArthur
Editions:ePub - First Edition: $ 2.99
ISBN: 978-1-64456-895-8
Pages: 291
Paperback - First Edition: $ 14.99
ISBN: 978-1-64456-894-1
Size: 5.50 x 8.50 in
Pages: 289

In the storm-battered New Mexico town of Benedición, three strangers discover that survival is not a matter of innocence — but of endurance.

A violent storm descends on the town—unnatural in its ferocity and persistence—trapping strangers and locals alike, cutting them off from escape and fraying the thin bonds of Benedición sanity. As floodwaters rise and tempers flare, old hatreds surface, and authority reveals its ugliest face.

Eli Mercer is only passing through. A big man with a past he does not discuss, Mercer intends to stay just long enough to dry out and move on. He has learned the cost of interference and prefers to keep out of other people’s troubles. But in Benedición, trouble does not stay contained. When a public spectacle turns into a brutal and unjust execution, Mercer is forced to choose between the safety of silence and the consequences of stepping in.

Eleanor Carrow did not come west seeking redemption. She came to practice medicine where it was most needed, where skill mattered more than pedigree, and where a woman willing to work hard and keep her head down might be tolerated, if never welcomed. In Benedición, she has carved out a precarious existence as the town’s doctor—respected in crisis, resented in calm, and always one wrong step away from being driven out.

Don Santiago de Álvarez knows what it means to be condemned without mercy. Accused, despised, and marked as an outsider, he endures the town’s bigotry with quiet dignity—but even endurance has limits. As fear spreads and violence becomes policy, survival may demand sacrifice beyond mere patience.

And beneath it all, something dark and older than the town watches.

A bitter payment is overdue.

A dark, atmospheric Western ghost story, A Reckoning in Mercy blends classic frontier realism with supernatural dread—where justice is uncertain, survival is costly, and the past is never truly forgiven.

Excerpt:

CHAPTER ONE

The Plateau is no place for the living.

A deep boom shook the air making the sand dance.

Startled, the rider halted.

No doubt about it, the rumbling came from ahead of him.  His body vibrated with it.  Something.  Someone.  Out there.  His skin tingled from the chill of recognition, never mind the desert heat.

The echo lingered in the distance, fading into oblivion.  The way forward wasn't clear.  But sure as hellfire and brimstone awaited, he couldn't go back.

Holding his breath, keeping still like prey sensing a predator nearby, Eli Mercer squinted against the harsh light, searching every point across his vista.  Nothing.

Behind him was emptiness.  Miles of sand strewn desert.  Beyond the wind, all he heard was ringing in his ears under the buzz of insects.  Occasional bird song.  Nothing to worry a man.

READ MORE

Shifting in his saddle, Mercer scanned the horizon again but found no source for the sound.

Alone.  No one followed him — at least not that he could see.  To be certain, he twisted around in his saddle and examined the road to the south.  Barren, save for that dead settlement.

Yet the wind, hollow and sputtering, complained more than usual.

Something was amiss.

While the contentment of solitude never fit him as a bespoke suit should, the wariness of paranoia was tailor cut for him.  He had to see for himself — he couldn't afford to take anyone else's word for it.  Not even the wind's.  Besides, it had lied to him before.

Another tremendous boom rattled the air, hovered over him, then slithered down into the earth — a rat-snake escaping the keen eye of a desert hawk.  All that lingered was the shrill whistle of the wind, still nagging at him that things were not as they should be.  To assure his attention, a gust blasted grit into his face.  He neither thanked nor cursed the wind for that.

The shriek of a magpie startled his horse as its black, white, and blue blur cut across in front of them.  It tangled with a thicket of dried brush then darted away.

Mercer's heartbeat throbbed in his chest.  Pounding, thumping, quick.  Sweat rolled down his skin, dripping down the inside of a soldier's neck stock, soaking his collar.  Sure as all men die someday, the desert was hot, yet stickiness clung to everything.

Heat and humidity.  They were nearing the big river that drew a line in the sand across his path.

His horse snorted and stamped, breaking him out of frozen time trapped inside his own mind, as a river bursts through an ice dam.  Mercer took a deep breath, drew himself up in pride, and patted his horse on the neck.  He was being foolish, after all, it was only him and his horse.  No one was out in the desert, save for maybe a few Indians who had better things to do than bother him.

Sweet sounds of nature.  No voices.  No screams.

Scalding late summer air rushed down the rising crest before him and across the flat lands behind, sending billows of pink and tan dust into the air, picking up the slain foliage of the desert oak, twisting and spraying a pine needle-filled blast down on him.  The soil smelled burnt and yet blanketed in a scent of sage, piñon, desperation, and thirst.  For all the tales told of the arid land, this year's Farmer's Almanac warned that 1888 was going to be the wettest year in memory.

Storms were coming.

Didn't seem likely in northwestern New Mexico where heat rises in waves from the ground and the sun smelts the dirt into hardened steel.

The weather was no excuse to slow down, let alone stop.  A twinge of self-pity tried its hand, but Mercer wouldn't play.  Why me snuck through his thoughts before he commanded the past to leave him the hell alone.

Mercer's big shadow told the old fable of the frontiersmen, which amused him.  He pulled the print cotton rag further up his nose and lowered his head allowing the wide brim of his hat to shield his eyes.  Strings of dull hair clung to the sweat on his brow.

The wind grew tired of nagging and tried to unseat him with a gust, like a joust in the days of old.  He'd read about those.  Experience and expectation kept him astride.  The upturned collar on a brown canvas coat, two thin shirts of differing fabrics, and gray woolen pants completed his only armor against the weather's onslaught.  No Lancelot here — merely a poor Sir Gawain on a godless quest.

And of that godless quest, his foremost weapon was motion.  North.  Hellfire — any direction.  But north is best.  Avoiding towns and people.  Always moving.  An Eternal Wanderer.

The grumpy grade horse he'd acquired on the Texas border had strong opinions regarding the flying dirt.  Nickering and stomping, she shook her head freeing her nose from the kerchief he'd draped over her nostrils to protect her.  Ingrate.  The cloth fell to the ground, whisked away in the next frenzied waft.  The wind was a thief as well as a liar, knowing he sure as hell wasn't going to chase it.

The horse he hadn't named — a pale blue-roan with natural points in a gorgeous black now dulled with salmon colored dust — stamped at the ground again.  Unimaginatively, he called her, "Girl," avoiding attachment to her.  She'd have to go, once they reached Aztec and the stage line.

Persnickety or not, Girl deserved his patience.  She put up with him.

Staring up the steep hill before him, he noted the clouds far, far above.  Fairy-like and sheer.  Such clouds were harbingers of change in the weather, something wise travelers and successful farmers marked with seriousness, or so he was learning.

Yet the rest of the skies above and behind were blue or dusty.  The problem ahead was the hill itself — it cut his view to the north, which he did not like.  Beyond lay a handful of rivers, bluffs, and mesas he needed to navigate, and the specific places he had to get to.  Moving, always moving.  Forward begged him to join in an embrace of hope and safety.  The notion of going backwards riled his stomach.  Backward meant —

The hair on both rider and horse's necks stood up as though a freeze came on suddenly.  The horse raised one hoof, as if to charge forward, yet waited — eyes wide, ears snapping in several directions.  Mercer sensed it too: the wrongness of nature defied.

COLLAPSE
Reviews:on Literary Titan:

A Reckoning in Mercy by T. E. MacArthur is a classic Western ghost story set in 1888 northwestern New Mexico, where Eli Mercer, a haunted drifter with an unwanted connection to the dead, rides into the town of Bendición during a violent storm and finds himself pulled into a fight involving corrupt lawmen, racial tension, old land claims, a condemned Hispano man named Don Santiago de Álvarez, and a determined woman doctor, Eleanor. What begins as a desperate search for shelter turns into a supernatural reckoning, with ghosts, guilt, and human cruelty all pressing in from every side.

MacArthur doesn’t treat the setting like painted scenery. The desert, the river, the storm, and the town all feel alive, and often hostile. I could feel the grit, the damp heat, the pressure in the air before something bad happened. The book leans into the Western side of its genre, with horses, guns, gallows, land disputes, and frontier politics, but the ghost story elements are woven in as something more than decoration. The supernatural feels tied to memory and violence, not just jump scares. That worked for me because I felt like it gave the story weight.

Mercer could have been a familiar wandering gunman, but he’s more interesting than that. He’s scared, guilty, proud, and trying very hard not to care until he clearly does. Eleanor is another strong point. She’s brave without feeling polished into perfection, and her presence sharpens the book’s ideas about who gets power, who gets believed, and who is allowed to stand in the way of injustice. The book is candid about prejudice and social hierarchy in the Old West, sometimes bluntly so, and while that can make parts of the story uncomfortable, but I think that discomfort is part of the point.

The prose is big and stormy, matching the story’s mood. Some scenes use heightened, dramatic language, especially during the action and supernatural moments, but that intensity fits the story because this isn’t a quiet little ghost tale. It’s dusty, bloody, strange, and restless. I would recommend A Reckoning in Mercy to readers who enjoy Western fiction with a paranormal edge, especially those who like morally wounded heroes, strong historical atmosphere, and ghost stories that are really about what refuses to stay buried.

on The Prairies Book Review:

Atmospheric, morally complex, and steeped in Southwestern folklore.

MacArthur’s latest sets a murder investigation against the backdrop of a flood-stricken frontier community where folklore, prejudice, and competing claims of justice collide. A violent storm strands drifter Eli Mercer in the isolated New Mexico town of Bendición just as a prominent landowner faces punishment for the murder of a young woman. With legal authority absent, Deputy Dill Tucker has transformed accusation into conviction, while Dr. Eleanor Carrow stands nearly alone in demanding evidence before judgment. When floodwaters cut the town off from the outside world, Mercer finds himself drawn into a conflict he has every reason to avoid.

MacArthur uses this premise to construct a novel that blends historical Western, murder mystery, and ghost story without allowing any one element to overwhelm the others. The strength of the narrative lies in the way its supernatural dimensions emerge from the same questions that drive the human conflict. The town’s fears, prejudices, and inherited divisions become inseparable from the haunting presence that hangs over the investigation. Mercer’s reluctance to become involved provides an effective counterpoint to Eleanor’s determination to pursue the truth despite mounting pressure. Their uneasy alliance anchors the novel while shifting suspicions and new discoveries sustain the mystery. Equally effective is MacArthur’s portrayal of the nineteenth-century Southwest, where competing cultures, histories, and loyalties shape every aspect of community life. The result is a thoughtful and atmospheric novel that uses the framework of a supernatural Western to examine how justice can be distorted when fear and certainty take the place of evidence.

A ghost story with a historian’s eye and a mystery writer’s discipline.